Comparison

E-boiler, heat pump or heat battery?

Anyone looking to electrify process heat comes across three technologies: the e-boiler, the industrial heat pump and the heat battery. They look like competitors, but they often complement each other. Below you will find the differences, and when a combination with heat storage delivers the most.

The three technologies side by side

Indicative values. What is achievable in your situation depends on your process, temperature, grid connection and energy prices.

E-boilerIndustrial heat pumpHyKro heat battery
How it worksConverts electricity directly into hot water or steam, using electrodes or resistance elements.Takes heat from a source such as waste heat, water or air and raises it to a higher temperature with a compressor.Converts electricity into heat, stores it in magnetite and releases it later through a heat exchanger.
TemperatureHot water and steam. With electric heaters, thermal oil too.Widely available up to about 100 °C. Between 100 and 200 °C emerging, from a limited number of suppliers.Storage up to 500 °C. Delivers steam, thermal oil or hot water for processes above 120 °C.
Energy efficiencyAbout 99%: 1 kWh of electricity becomes almost 1 kWh of heat.COP of 2.5 to 6: 1 kWh of electricity delivers 2.5 to 6 kWh of heat. The larger the temperature lift, the lower the COP.Over 90% across a full charge and discharge cycle. Heat loss 0.5 to 1% per day.
StorageNone. The heat must be used immediately.None. Ideally runs as many hours as possible.8 MWh per module: up to about 40 hours of heat at full output.
Demand on the gridFull power, at the moment the process needs heat. Often not possible where the grid is congested.Lower than an e-boiler thanks to the high COP, but continuous during operation.Charges when the grid has capacity or power is cheap. Then delivers heat without drawing power from the grid.
Steering on power priceOnly if heat demand happens to coincide with cheap hours. Alongside a gas boiler, an e-boiler without a buffer often runs only 1,000 to 1,500 hours a year.Limited: the heat pump runs when the process needs heat.Fully: charges at the cheapest hours of the day or on your own solar power, and delivers when the process asks for it.
InvestmentLow per MW of capacity.High per MW. Pays off with many running hours and a small temperature lift.Higher than an e-boiler, but far lower per MWh stored than a lithium-ion battery.
Best suited toA generous grid connection, a flexible process and the wish to start as cheaply as possible.Heat demand up to about 150 °C, an available heat source and many running hours per year.Heat above 120 °C, a limited grid connection, own generation or the wish to steer on power price.

E-boiler plus heat storage: more hours of cheap power

An e-boiler is a cheap and quick way to turn electricity into heat. The downside: it only delivers heat while it runs. If you only want to heat during cheap hours, you often have too few hours. And if you want to be able to heat at any time, you need a large grid connection.

Adding heat storage changes that. Experience shows that an electric boiler with a thermal buffer delivers two to three times as much heat as without one, and that the value of each flexible megawatt roughly doubles.

The HyKro heat battery is essentially an electric heater with built-in storage. Already have an e-boiler, or considering one? They can work side by side. During cheap hours, the e-boiler feeds the process directly while the battery charges. During expensive hours, or when the grid is full, the battery takes over.

Heat pump plus heat battery: each at its own temperature

An industrial heat pump is the most efficient way to make heat, as long as the temperature lift stays small. Above about 150 °C it gets difficult, and above 200 °C no heat pumps are available yet. It also needs a heat source and prefers to run as many hours as possible.

A heat battery has none of those limits, but converts electricity into heat one to one. The combination plays to the strengths of both:

  • The heat pump covers the base load and the lower-temperature part, such as preheating boiler feed water or upgrading waste heat.
  • The heat battery supplies the high temperature and covers peaks, using power bought at the cheapest hours.

The heat pump can stay smaller, and the installation as a whole draws less peak power from the grid.

And the gas boiler?

Most companies keep their gas boiler as a backup for now. That makes sense: security of supply stays the same and the electric share grows step by step.

The numbers are shifting, though. From 2028, ETS2 puts a European carbon price on natural gas for companies outside the current EU ETS as well. Every MWh of heat that does not have to come from the gas boiler becomes more valuable.

Which solution fits you?

A first pointer:

  • Heat below 100 °C and a source of waste heat? Start with a heat pump.
  • A generous grid connection and a flexible process? An e-boiler may be the cheapest first step.
  • Heat above 120 °C, grid congestion or your own solar power? Then a heat battery is worth considering, alone or combined with an e-boiler or heat pump.

In the free heat battery quick scan we run the numbers for your situation. If another technology fits better, we will tell you honestly.

Want to compare all options first, using your own consumption data? In the energy simulation we work out three scenarios, including generation, grid contract and subsidies.

Which combination fits your process?

Tell us your heat demand, temperature and grid connection. We will show what a heat battery, alone or alongside an e-boiler or heat pump, can do for you.